5 best energy-efficient light bulbs
With a new energy-efficiency rule taking effect, manufacturers are stepping up their lighting options. Here are the most switch-worthy products.
In response to a new energy-efficiency law, manufacturers are producing more light-bulb varieties than ever. While they're all touted as 60-watt soft-white equivalents, we found quite a range in brightness and color. Here are some of the most switch-worthy options.
NOTE: We gauged efficiency based on the most usable light emitted per watt within a 220-degree arc from a bulb.
On average, compact fluorescent bulbs took 94 seconds to fully brighten in our tests. But General Electric's Bright From the Start Soft White Hybrid Halogen-CFL 15W ($12.44 for two) solves this problem, combining the instant-on illumination of a halogen with the superior energy efficiency of a CFL. We found that it is 485% more efficient than a traditional bulb. Claimed life span: 8,000 hours (about seven years).
- Bing: Projects that increase a home's value
- MSN Living: Expert interior lighting tips
- Video: Energy-efficient bulbs can carry new risks
The light cast from the dimmable GE Crystal Clear Halogen A19 43W Bulb ($5 for two) rated highest with our testers, who even preferred it to that of the traditional soft-white incandescent bulb — and we found it 43% more efficient. Claimed life span: 1,000 hours (about a year), but the one we're cycling on and off has lasted 1,500 hours and counting.
Get ideas for your home with our inspirational rooms and direct access to real products.
Click here to begin exploring.
Philips' Energy Saver Mini Twister 13W in Soft White ($8 for four) brightens quickly for a CFL: in 45 seconds. Feit's Soft White Ecobulb Plus 13W ($4) was a crowd favorite, but takes two minutes to warm up. In terms of efficiency, these rated even better on our test than the winning LEDs — 587% and 593% more efficient, respectively, than an incandescent. Claimed life spans: 10,000 and 12,000 hours (about nine and 11 years).
Don't let the yellow exterior of Philips' AmbientLED A19 12.5W ($25) turn you off — it emits a lovely soft-white glow. It's also dimmable and does an excellent job of spreading light uniformly in all directions — no small feat for an LED, which generally produces more directional light. Our tests show it to be 512% more efficient than a 60-watt bulb. Claimed life span: 25,000 hours (about 23 years).
- Subscribe to MSN Real Estate on Facebook and Twitter
- How much are homes really worth near you?
- Bing: What do energy tax credits cover?
LED by a mile
Consumers loved the brighter white of EcoSmart LED A19 13W ($25), which cast light impressively evenly in all directions. Our tests revealed it to be 501% more efficient than a comparable incandescent, and it's even brighter. Claimed life span: 25,000 hours (about 23 years).
- On our blog, 'Listed': Balancing a small room and a big TV
- Video: How much money are light bulbs costing you?
- MSN Money: Do programmable thermostats really save money?
How we tested
We tested 28 soft-white halogen, CFL and LED bulbs that claimed light output similar to that of best-selling, traditional 60-watt incandescents. Our engineers measured each bulb's brightness, the evenness of its illumination, the time it took to fully brighten (CFLs are known to have a "warm-up" period), its energy efficiency and its endurance. We also asked consumers to rate light quality — yes, these technologies produce light you'll actually like.
To test how long-lasting these new bulbs are, Good Housekeeping Research Institute test engineer Erik Eibert left one set blazing and made an apparatus to turn a second set on and off at 15-minute intervals (frequently turning CFLs on and off shortens their lives). In this accelerated test, all 17 exceeded expected life span.
GHRI insight: CFLs are the best value. Their electricity usage is comparable to that of LEDs; while they have about a third the life span, three still cost a lot less than one LED (on average, $9 versus $25). That said, the price of Philips' AmbientLED has dropped by more than a third since its launch. Stay tuned.