Family paid for streetlights for 25 years

Utility company initially refuses to reimburse Connecticut customer for erroneous charges, arguing that she should have complained sooner.

By Teresa at MSN Real Estate Aug 15, 2012 12:08PM

Jaime Monfort/Getty ImagesHere's a reminder that it's important to understand all the charges on your utility bills: A Connecticut woman paid 25 years for the electricity for two streetlights in an enclave at the end of her street.

 

"[Connecticut Light & Power] said it was always on the bill and up to me to inform them of the mistake," Grace Edwards told The Hartford Courant. "I said, 'How could I inform you of something I didn't know about?'"

 

You'd think that once a homeowner discovered such a mistake, getting credit for the erroneous charges -- about $20 a month -- would have been easy. But that wasn't Edwards' experience.

 

She got the runaround from the power company and also from the agency that regulates utility companies, she told The Courant.

The power company agreed to remove the streetlights from Edwards' bill but initially refused to reimburse her, saying she should have noticed the mistake sooner.

But Edward argued that the information on the bill wasn't easy to decipher. It merely said "9500 Lumen HP Sodium" and "6300 Lumen HP Sodium." This wasn't necessarily clear evidence that she was paying someone else's electric bill for streetlights – not something any of us would expect to find on our utility bills among all the taxes, fees and other items.

The charge stemmed from an agreement that builder of the subdivision, who was the former owner of her home, had made a quarter-century ago. The charges should have disappeared when Edwards and her husband, now deceased, bought the home in the Hartford community of Cheshire.

Finally, after Edwards contacted another state agency and the newspaper, she got a check for $10,491.21 -- about $5,800 in erroneous charges plus interest -- and an apology from CL&P.

 

As Taren O'Connor, the consumer information representative for the Office of Consumer Counsel, told The Courant: "You trust when you call and someone is pulling up your history and your bills, you think that they might say, 'Oh, wait a minute. Did you realize you are paying for two street lights?' Because I'm guessing that is not normal."

Tags: celebrity
54Comments
Sep 3, 2012 8:58AM
avatar

Good for her!  Rarely do the little people recieve justice when contending w/ the corporate world.  Glad that she was made whole.

 

Sep 1, 2012 10:10PM
avatar
wel this happend to me , my neibor was very angry at us  she saw my electric  an it was cheap  compare to hers  the next month  the electric company wanted to change my meter  i said ok , they for got to change the meter number  on the bill  wel i got a big bill  the next month , i paid it  an  i did catch the misstake  they give me a credit  , but it made my neibor more angry , jealous people  omg  , plus i look at every bill phone gas electric  check every charge  question the ones i dont under stand
Sep 1, 2012 9:06PM
avatar
The company new that charging an individual homeowner for street lights is/was wrong.  Then why isn't intentional wrongful charges not fraud???? 
Sep 1, 2012 6:29PM
Sep 1, 2012 6:14PM
avatar
thats pitiful, ripping off the old folks like that, not cool, Im glad I dont live their
Sep 1, 2012 5:14PM
avatar
not everyone understands what a lumen is nor that the sodium vapor lamps are street lights
Sep 1, 2012 4:09PM
avatar
u mean they were overbilled for 25 yrs and never realized it?????????
Sep 1, 2012 3:41PM
avatar

actually this is not at all unusual. in the city limits where i live, the city pays for the street lights out of the city's yearly budget,...which they fund through our taxes of course. but in the individual neighborhoods, if a homeowner feels they aren't well lit and they want more lights, they can request the electric company add a street light to a nearby pole and they will be billed for the light's electricity. if you examine your bill you will see that fees and taxes are labelled "fee" or "tax". if there was anything else added to her bill, she should have asked what it was and they would have explained the charge. it was HER RESPONSIBLITY to check her bill. its called PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY. She contributed to her own victimization through her own ignorance or negligance, and she should NOT have been given a refund.  

Sep 1, 2012 3:31PM
avatar
  Everyone, check your electric bill and if you have it, gas bill. You will notice that they charge every homeowner $5.00 (in my area) a home to read the meter. They can stand in my yard and use the scanner and read four meters. I asked about that and the reader said yes if he has a clear view of the neighbors meter he can do it.I remember when I used to read  MY OWN METER. I grew up on a farm and we read our own ELECTRIC meter every month.
Sep 1, 2012 3:04PM
avatar
I was moving into a new place, met the cable guy and told him I had to run and would return shortly. I arrived as he was leaving. Asked him if everything was hooked up and tested,t.v&internet. He responded yep. I unpacked the t.v. made the connections and all is good. Go to set up the computer and find no internet. Spend a couple of hours trying to figure out what I done wrong and then gave up. Phoned the cable company and was told 2 weeks before anyone would be out and I had to book  a full day off work. Turns out the first guy never even hooked up  the net. Fought with the cable company for reinbursement to no avail. Unless you go to the press and it is a sizeable amount of money, forget about ever seeing your stolen money.
Sep 1, 2012 2:20PM
avatar
Good she got the money before my sleazy lawyer got wind of the situation, he probably still wants his "fee".
Sep 1, 2012 2:02PM
avatar

Have you ever noticed with stories like this that nothing was getting done until she contacted a newspaper? 

 

And my power and gas companies want to know why I refuse to have my payments automatically deducted from my account.

Sep 1, 2012 11:31AM
avatar
I had a situation where i was paying for my neighbors electric bill, and they were paying mine.  i noticed a very high bill even though i wasnt running my a/c.  i looked at the meter number on the bill and compared it to my meter.  they had swapped them.  it took 5 phone calls, 2 visits from a comed "meter reader" and a complaint to the agency that monitors comed to get any reults.  it took 4 months for them to admit the mistake, and another 2 months to get the adjustment on my bill.  once it was all done i got a letter blaming the contractor that built the townhome.  
Sep 1, 2012 11:25AM
avatar
It is really hard to decipher what the charges mean....and I think generally we tend to trust that it is right.  I always check my bill no matter what it is and has proved in my favor.  Even if I don't understand what the charges are I call and have them tell me.  I can tell the people on the other line are annoyed by it sometimes but other times it's proved worthwhile...especially when they charged me for a c-section and circumcision when I did a natural birth with no drugs and had a girl.  That was a doozie!  It explains now why they kept referring to me as Theresa when that wasn't my name. 
Sep 1, 2012 10:30AM
avatar
For what it's worth, EVERYONE should regularly check their bills to make sure you understand everything on the bill.  If the bill isn't itemized, as for it to be itemize at least a couple of times a year.  Keep in mind that overpaying is bad but, underpaying can be far worse.  In most places you are still liable to make up any underpayment.
Sep 1, 2012 9:24AM
avatar
I have for 14 years thought my electric bill was to high and we have done things like use a clothes line in the warm months and use energy saving light bulbs and they have lowered it but not to what I thought should be enough so I thought well maybe we have a short underground between our meter and our house so I shut the disconnect off the one that is a couple inches under the meter and watched it and the meter kept turning it was slow but it kept going. So I called them and told them what I had done and that the meter was still running and ask them if they would check it to see if there meter was working properly and they told me NO they said that the only thing there meter would do if it did mess up would be to run slower and that if I  wanted it checked to see if something else was tapped into it I would have to hire an electrician to check it out and that even if there was something hooked up on the backside of my meter then they were steeling my electricity and not there's so it was my problem. Now I did ask an electrician about this and he told me that chances are the meter connections are corroded or loose and that is creating heat which in turn is drawing power. They also told me that if they did come and check it out then they would have to bill me. I then ask well what is all this so called service charge for on my bill and she told me that was for what she had just done giving me advice on what to do.
Sep 1, 2012 8:32AM
avatar
Even if this woman did not understand the bill, she should have called years ago to question it. If I receive a bill and there is something I don't understand I question it. Simple, right?
Proof that many people do not pay attention and they just pay. Proof that companies know this and obscure certain things.
Sep 1, 2012 7:19AM
avatar
MCI keeps billing me for monthly charges for long distance for about the past year... just the monthly service charge because I'm not using the long distance.  Why am I not using the long distance? BECAUSE THEY SIGNED US UP FOR LONG DISTANCE ON A PHONE NUMBER WE HAVEN'T USED FOR 12 YEARS!!!!!  I have called them repeatedly and spent hours on the phone.  Every time, after a run around, they say they will "cancel our service".  And I remind them I am not paying the bill, either and that needs to be credited.  And wouldn't you think if I didn't pay they'd turn it off?  NOOOOOOO....  they just keep adding to the bill every month and sending it.  Except now it's at a collection agency.  I HATE MCI!  Years ago they slammed us and charged us 7.00 a minute for long distance, which resulted in a 2000.00 bill that took me 2 years to get corrected.  This time it's going to the State Attorney General's office.
Sep 1, 2012 7:10AM
avatar
"She got the runaround from the power company and also from the agency that regulates utility companies..."
Yes, "the runaround" is what I've always gotten when trying to correct any kind of error with any kind of company or organization.  I think they teach The Runaround 101 at most training seminars.  I've had employers who have tried to involve me in runaround situations with clients, and I simply refused to participate, which was always the beginning of the end of my job.  As a decent human being, I will simply hand the ball to the piggy in the middle because he or she is going to get it one way or another ANYWAY, through litigation or simply by spreading the word to other potential clients via national media outlets, which is what this woman did.  Making the piggy feel like a piggy, that is, humiliated, frustrated, bullied, and betrayed, is only going to harm your company.
Watch out for the Triangle of Manipulation where the blame gets passed to someone else, not present, who may or may not be reachable through such means as telephone, mail, e-mail, appointment, skywriting, tin can and string, etc.  That person isn't really responsible, nor will they end up helping you.  
Also, it doesn't matter if you read the fine print.  They will invariably tell you that it doesn't say what you THINK it says, but rather the exact opposite, or that one paragraph voids the next or that your state laws make your signature summon magical elves that will smash your windshield if you file a claim.  The best weapon is communication via registered post, preferably with the return address being your lawyer's office.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

About Teresa Mears

Teresa Mears

Teresa Mears is a veteran journalist who has been interested in houses since her father took her to tax auctions to carry the cash at age 10. A former editor of The Miami Herald's Home & Design section, she lives in South Florida where, in addition to writing about real estate, she publishes Miami on the Cheap to help her neighbors adjust to the loss of 60% of their property value.

FIND YOUR DREAM HOME OR APARTMENT

or

WHAT'S YOUR HOME WORTH?

    

HOME IMPROVEMENT PROFESSIONALS

Find local plumbers, electricians, contractors and more.

from our partners